Difference Between Pool Refinishing and Pool Resurfacing: Pros and Cons

Keeping a pool looking good, safe and built to last takes a bit of upkeep over the years. When the surface starts to show its age, you’ve generally got two options: pool refinishing or pool resurfacing. Both will freshen up the pool, but they’re quite different jobs when it comes to what’s involved, the materials used and the cost. Knowing how the two compare makes it a lot easier to pick the right one for your pool and your budget.

Below we’ll run through what each one involves, the pros and cons of both, and a few things worth thinking about before you decide.

What is Pool Refinishing?

Pool refinishing means applying a fresh coating over the existing pool surface, whether that surface is bare or already painted. It’s mainly a cosmetic job: it lifts the look of the pool and adds a layer of protection against everyday wear.

Pros of Pool Refinishing

• It’s an affordable way to tidy up the surface and keep it looking good.
• The job is usually done in about two days, so the pool isn’t out of action for long.
• There’s a good range of finishes to choose from, so you can freshen up the look however you like.
• A fresh coat also adds a bit of protection against staining and algae.

Cons of Pool Refinishing

• The coating doesn’t last long, so it’s more of a short-term fix than a permanent one.
• It only covers the surface. Cracks, leaks and deeper damage are left untouched.
• Depending on how much the pool is used and how harsh the chemicals are, you’ll likely be redoing it every three to five years.

What is Pool Resurfacing?

Resurfacing a pool is a bigger job. The old surface is stripped right back and a brand new one goes on in its place, using a material like plaster, tiles, quartz or fibreglass. As well as giving the pool a fresh look, it strengthens the surface underneath.

Pros of Pool Resurfacing

• Lasts far longer: A resurfaced pool will typically go 10 to 20 years before it needs doing again, depending on the material.
• Fixes the real problems: Cracks, leaks and worn surfaces are all repaired as part of the job, not just covered over.
• Better water quality: A fresh surface makes it easier to keep algae and the water chemistry under control.
• Plenty of choice: You can go with plaster, pebbles, tiles or fibreglass, whatever suits the pool and the look you want.

Cons of Pool Resurfacing

• Costs more: Between the extra labour and the materials, it’s a bigger outlay than refinishing.
• Takes longer: Depending on how involved the job is, the pool can be out of action for up to a couple of weeks.
• Best left to the pros: Resurfacing is not a DIY job. Get the application wrong and the mistakes can be expensive to put right.

Key Differences Between Pool Refinishing and Pool Resurfacing

When Should You Choose Pool Refinishing?

• The surface looks a bit tired but is still structurally sound.
• You want a quick freshen-up without spending much.
• You’re selling the house and want the pool to present well.
• You need a stopgap before committing to a full resurfacing job later on.

When Should You Choose Pool Resurfacing?

• There are visible cracks, leaks or heavy wear.
• You want a long-term fix that won’t need much upkeep.
• The old surface has broken down to the point where it’s affecting the water.
• You’re upgrading to a better finish, such as tiles or fibreglass.

Choosing the Right Option for Your Pool

The simple version: if the surface is worn but the structure is fine, refinishing is the quick, affordable option. If there are cracks, leaks or deeper damage, swimming pool resurfacing is the one that’ll actually last.

Additional Considerations

• How often it’s used: A pool that gets a lot of use will hold up better with resurfacing.
• Climate: Harsh weather wears a finish down faster, which is worth factoring in.
• Budget: Think of refinishing as a short-term fix and resurfacing as a longer-term investment.
• Pool type: Fibreglass, concrete and vinyl pools each have their own resurfacing needs.

Outbound Resources for Further Reading

Want to read further on pool care and surface materials? These are worth a look:

• Swimming Pool and Spa Association of Australia (SPASA) – guidance on pool care and materials.
• NSW Fair Trading, Pool Safety and Regulations – the compliance rules for pool owners in NSW.

Final Thoughts

Both refinishing and resurfacing have their place. It really comes down to the state of your pool, what you want to spend, and how long you need the result to last. If you just want a quick cosmetic lift, refinishing is the budget pick. If you’re after something that lasts, resurfacing is the better investment.

Pool resurfacing is what we do best here at Fibrestyle, and we’re happy to take a look and tell you honestly which option makes more sense for your pool. Get in touch whenever you’re ready.

Get Started Today!

Is your pool due for a makeover? Get in touch for a free pool resurfacing quote and we’ll help you bring it back to life.